5 min read · Evergreen guide
How to compare roofing estimates after a storm
After a storm, compare written roofing estimates by the work included, the materials proposed, and the contract terms. A lower total can reflect a different scope. Ask each contractor to explain the inspection findings and any exclusions before you decide.
Discuss your project
Start with documented inspection findings
Before comparing proposals, request a documented roof inspection. Ask which areas were inspected, which conditions were observed, and how the findings support repair or replacement. Keep photographs and notes with each estimate so you can compare the proposed work with the same evidence.
Coverage depends on the insurance policy, the facts of the damage, and the insurer’s determination. A roofing contractor cannot guarantee claim approval. Ask your insurer about its documentation requirements and keep the contractor’s estimate separate from any assumption about coverage.
Check that each estimate covers the same work
A full tear-off and replacement, an overlay, and a partial repair are different projects. Compare the measured roof area, removal work, retained components, and proposed materials before comparing the total price. Ask for clarification when one quote includes an item that another omits.
- Measured work area and inspection findings supporting the recommendation.
- Tear-off, hauling and disposal; items that remain in place.
- Roof covering manufacturer and product, underlayment and accessories.
- Flashing at walls, chimneys, valleys and penetrations.
- Ventilation work and the reason it is proposed.
- Permits, property protection, cleanup and access arrangements.
- Schedule, payment terms, exclusions and change-order process.
Make concealed-damage allowances explicit
An inspection cannot reveal every condition beneath existing shingles. Ask how additional decking work will be photographed, priced and approved if it becomes necessary after removal. Clarify whether the proposal includes an allowance, a unit price, or neither.
Vague labels such as miscellaneous or contingency do not explain what is covered. Before work begins, ask which conditions could create an additional charge and who will contact you for approval. Do not assume a missing line item is included.
Compare materials, flashing and ventilation
Ask for the exact proposed shingle or roof-covering product, rather than a broad description alone. Review what the proposal says about underlayment, flashing and ventilation. Where a component will be reused, ask the contractor to explain its condition and why reuse is recommended.
A detailed estimate should make the work easier to understand. If two contractors recommend different approaches, ask each to connect the recommendation to the roof’s observed condition. Request clarification in writing before treating the proposals as equivalent.
Read warranties and exclusions together
A product warranty and a contractor’s workmanship warranty may cover different matters. Request the applicable documents and ask who provides each warranty, what is excluded, and how a concern should be reported. Do not assume that a warranty covers every future leak.
Compare the payment schedule and completion expectations alongside the scope. A proposal with fewer included items may have a lower initial total but require additional work. Your comparison should make those differences visible before you choose.
Keep storm documentation organized
Keep inspection notes, photographs, proposals and insurer correspondence together. Missing documentation can make it harder to establish what happened; it does not by itself determine the insurer’s decision. Ask questions about coverage directly to your insurer.
After the work, review the completed scope with the contractor and raise any open questions. Retain the final documents and warranty information so you can refer to them later.
Use a final side-by-side checklist
For each estimate, write down the answer to these questions. Mark missing information as needs clarification instead of filling in assumptions.
- Do all proposals cover the same roof area and type of work?
- Are the materials and retained components identified?
- How are hidden damage and additional charges handled?
- What protection, cleanup and final review are included?
- Which warranties, exclusions and payment terms apply?
- What must I clarify before signing?
Plan your next step
Compare scope, materials and written terms before choosing on price. Use the related inspection, storm-damage and replacement services below to prepare for a conversation about your property. An estimate request is a starting point for assessment, not a guarantee of insurance coverage or a completed booking.
Explore the services for your project
Find your local team
Related guides
Next step
Get a free roof estimate
Tell us about your property. We inspect, explain the recommended work, and provide a written estimate so you can make a confident decision.